Marketizing Anticipation
Prediction Markets, Platform Signals, and the Participatory Forecasting of Cultural Futures
This proposal asks how the logic of prediction markets may be taking shape in the everyday infrastructure of media platforms. Formal markets aggregate dispersed beliefs about future outcomes; platforms estimate future attention and allocate visibility in response to their own signals.
On the production side, platforms, marketers and creators act on anticipated performance before an audience has assembled. On the participatory side, audiences vote, pledge, pre-order and sometimes wager on what may succeed. The project studies how these linked practices shape cultural futures.
Research questions
- How do platforms, brands, and creators construct and act upon predictive signals such as trending likelihood and engagement velocity, and in what respects does this practice reproduce the informational logic of a prediction market?
- Through what platform affordances and user practices are audiences enrolled as participatory forecasters and co-producers of brand and cultural futures, and what draws them to take part?
- What follows for cultural production and imagination: which futures does the marketization of anticipation render visible and valuable, whose anticipations are counted, and what possibilities are foreclosed?
A framework for anticipatory media
I call this process the marketization of anticipation: beliefs about the future are aggregated, quantified and used to guide decisions in the present. A platform does more than read the likely outcome. Its rankings, recommendations and metrics can help produce that outcome.
The revised forecast becomes the next signal.
How I would study it
Study 1Predictive signals and platform surfaces+
Study 1 reconstructs how predictive signals are made and shown (RQ1). I will assemble parallel corpora from two sites that price cultural futures in contrasting ways: formal markets on entertainment and award outcomes, drawing on Kalshi, Polymarket, and archival Hollywood Stock Exchange data, and the trending and recommendation surfaces of major content platforms. Interface and content analysis will document how each renders the future legible, how categories such as trending, predicted, and likely to go viral are displayed and to whom, while network analysis and time-series methods will examine how early engagement velocity anticipates later diffusion. The aim is not to build a better virality model but to describe, in Mackenzie’s (2015) sense, what these systems take prediction to be for (Seaver, 2017).
Study 2Reading and acting on metrics+
Study 2 turns to the people who read and act on those signals (RQ1, RQ2). Through semi-structured interviews and reflexive thematic analysis with marketers, analytics and growth staff, trend forecasters, and creators, I will examine how predictive metrics are interpreted, trusted, contested, and folded into decisions, attending to the algorithmic imaginaries that organize this work (Bucher, 2017; Petre, 2021). Having directed consumer brands and creator collaborations myself, I bring insider familiarity to these settings, which is both an analytic resource and a source of bias to be managed reflexively rather than wished away.
Study 3Audience participation and cultural futures+
Study 3 examines participation from the audience side (RQ2, RQ3). Comparative cases of features that recruit users as forecasters, from fan voting and prediction mechanics to crowdfunding, pre-orders, and play-money or real-money cultural markets, will be analyzed for their affordances and their social life. A survey analyzed with structural equation modeling will test how anticipation, parasocial attachment, and a felt sense of co-ownership relate to participation, while follow-up interviews recover meanings the numbers cannot. This study speaks most directly to questions of agency and inclusion, that is, whose forecasts are solicited, on what terms, and with what consequences for those whose anticipations go unrecorded (Appadurai, 2013).
A final speculative probe extends critique into making. I will prototype an anticipatory-media interface that renders the marketization of attention visible and open to contestation, and use it to elicit reflection from users and practitioners.
Why this matters
A forecast that changes what people make and see cannot be judged as if it were detached from its subject. The project connects prediction-market theory, studies of anticipation, platform research and participatory culture to ask how cultural futures are made, valued and foreclosed.



